I have the buddy club and wish I would have just gotten the acuity. I bought it second hand so I'm not sure what the quality of it was right out of the box. The plastic ball that rests in the main plastic housing has a ton of slop. It feels more than twice as sloppy as stock. If anyone is looking for a cheap way to shorten the throw, I suggest just getting the small metal extension that clips on the bottom of the stock shifter (I think bwr makes one) rather than the buddy club. Then getting a bushing kit to reduce the slop. The play from the ball on the buddy club is so bad. Acuity is definitely the way to go in the end though.