I'll have to get a picture next time I swing by the garage. Picture a wheel after someone threw a handful of gravel at it. Nothing crazy, just a bunch of little chips.
Good news though. We got in touch with someone at Rotiform, not easy since they don't list a phone number, and they apparently have thousands of these wheels around the warehouse. Reached out to a vendor and got a new one at a discounted price. Guess they discontinued them since the color was so hard to paint. Said the finishes varied from batch to batch. Dude laughed when I asked if a shop would be able to paint match.